Trump loses bid to maintain tape out of rape defamation case
Former U.S. President Donald Trump reacts throughout an occasion held to deal with the current derailment of a practice carrying hazardous waste, in East Palestine, Ohio, U.S., February 22, 2023.
Alan Freed | Reuters
A federal decide on Friday dominated that the “Entry Hollywood” tape revealing former President Donald Trump bragging about groping ladies with out their prior consent could possibly be used as proof in a civil trial the place he’s accused of defaming the author E. Jean Carroll after she claimed her raped within the mid-Nineties.
Decide Lewis Kaplan additionally dominated that testimony from two different ladies who say that Trump sexually assaulted them years in the past in separate incidents might be launched into proof on the trial in U.S. District Court docket in Manhattan.
Kaplan in his choice wrote, “Many of the proof that Mr. Trump seeks to maintain from the trial jury is to the impact that Mr. Trump allegedly has abused or tried to abuse ladies apart from Ms. Carroll in methods which might be similar to what he allegedly did to Ms. Carroll.”
Trump, 76, has denied raping the now-79-year-old Carroll, who says he attacked her in a dressing room on the Bergdorf Goodman’s division retailer after an opportunity encounter there in 1995 or 1996.
Carroll’s go well with alleges that Trump defamed her in 2019 after she went public along with her declare by saying she was mendacity, and motivated by politics and cash to make up the account.
“In different phrases,” the decide wrote, “Ms. Carroll gives the proof to indicate that Mr. Trump has a propensity for such habits.”
The “Entry Hollywood” tape, was recorded in 2005 however solely turned public simply earlier than the 2016 election, when Trump was first looking for the presidency.
“I am routinely interested in lovely ladies — I simply begin kissing them, it is like a magnet. Simply kiss. I do not even wait,” Trump says on that tape.
“And once you’re a star, they allow you to do it. You are able to do something. “Seize ’em by the p—-.”
Trump has repeatedly claimed that his remarks on the tape are “locker room discuss,” and don’t replicate his precise conduct.
However Kaplan in his ruling wrote, “On this case, a jury moderately might discover, even from the Entry Hollywood tape alone, that Mr. Trump admitted within the Entry Hollywood tape that he in truth has had contact with ladies’s genitalia up to now with out their consent, or that he had tried to take action.”
Due to that, and different proof, the tape satisfies a rule that permits proof of one other sexual assault to be launched in a civil case involving an alleged sexual assault, Kaplan wrote.
Kaplan for a similar motive dominated that the claims towards Trump by two different ladies who’ve given depositions within the case, Jessica Leeds and Natasha Stoynoff, might be heard by jurors.
Leeds testified in her deposition that in 1979 Trump tried to kiss her, grabbed her breasts and put his hand up her skirt on an airplane after a stewardess invited her to sit down subsequent to him in firstclass.
Stoynoff testified that in 2005, when she was writing an article for Folks journal about his one-year wedding ceremony anniversary with Melania Trump, he grabbed her, pushed her towards a wall and commenced kissing her in a room at his Mar-a-Lago membership in Palm Seaside, Florida.
Trump’s lawyer Joseph Tacopina declined to touch upon the ruling by Kaplan.
That is breaking information. Please verify again for updates.