MG ZS EV vs Nissan Leaf
As extra producers discover electrical tech, the trickle-down continues to penetrate the decrease automotive lessons, democratising zero-emissions motoring for a lot of.
The newest inexpensive EV mannequin to emerge comes from MG. The Chinese language-owned, reborn British model is providing fairly a robust proposition with its ZS EV SUV, as a easy have a look at the numbers exhibits: £26,995 for the top-spec Unique mannequin and a claimed WLTP vary of 163 miles.
• Finest electrical automobiles on sale
This implies the MG faces a key rival the Nissan Leaf, a automotive that pioneered inexpensive electrical motoring. At this worth it’s the top-spec MG versus the entry-level Nissan – however with regards to energy, vary and charging, the 2 are shut.
|Mannequin:||MG ZS EV Unique||Nissan Leaf 40kWh Acenta|
|Engine:||1x electrical motor, 44.5kWh Li-ion battery||1x electrical motor, 40kWh Li-ion battery|
|Transmission:||Single-speed automated, front-wheel drive||Single-speed automated, front-wheel drive|
|0-60mph:||7.Four seconds||7.eight seconds|
|Check effectivity:||3.6 miles/kWh||3.6 miles/kWh|
|Choices:||Metallic paint (£545)||None|
MG ZS EV
For: Vary and affordability, stronger, extra versatile recharging functionality, respectable practicality and equipment.
Towards: Trip and dealing with could possibly be extra managed, infotainment lacks EV-specific performance.
Key to any EV is its battery. This determines the usable vary on provide, in addition to the automotive’s efficiency, and within the ZS EV the engineering and tech are fairly good given the worth. The 44.5kWh battery complete means round 40kWh of usable capability, and MG claims 163 miles on a full cost.
The battery provides a 141bhp electrical motor that drives the entrance wheels. That is 7bhp down on the Leaf, however then the MG is 41kg lighter. The ZS EV’s efficiency on take a look at was greater than ample, with the 353Nm of torque (33Nm greater than the Leaf) delivered immediately for sturdy and easy acceleration.
It sprinted from 0-60mph in 7.Four seconds, 0.Four seconds sooner than the Leaf, however by 60mph the MG’s urgency tails off (its high pace is barely 87mph). Acceleration from decrease speeds is extra essential to extra individuals, and on this occasion, the ZS managed 30-50mph in 2.7 seconds, in comparison with 2.eight seconds within the Leaf, so there’s little to separate them. This acceleration is what makes smaller EVs like these simple and enjoyable to drive in city areas.
They’re helped by single-speed transmissions. With no gearchanges, you simply squeeze the throttle and go. There are three driving modes within the ZS: Eco, Regular and Sport. Eco and Regular are the nicest, as a result of the throttle response ramps up in every setting, and it’s a bit of too aggressive in Sport.
There’s a little bit of motor whine as you carry off, however in any other case refinement is fairly good – and this extends, principally, to the journey. The ZS feels pretty gentle, bouncing a good bit with unfastened physique management, however a minimum of the chassis offers with softer undulations within the highway easily; larger, harsher bumps trigger the wheels to rebound fairly aggressively, with an inexpensive, barely crude really feel to the best way the dampers take care of controlling the wheels.
The Leaf isn’t immune from this both, however it’s higher than within the MG. The ZS’s steering is gentle and imprecise, however acceptable, and makes it simple to navigate round city. It’s no driver’s automotive although.
High-spec Unique trim options air-con, keyless operation, adaptive cruise, an eight-inch touchscreen set-up with sat-nav and smartphone connectivity, a panoramic roof, heated seats and a few nice security tech for the cash as a part of MG’s Pilot system.
Inevitably, given this equipment tally and the stable engineering beneath, it’s the extent of high quality of the remainder of the automotive that is available in for questioning. The inside plastics are exhausting and, though they really feel strong, they don’t really feel notably excessive in high quality. However then this does preserve the worth down, which is essential at this degree of the market.
- • High quality: Total match and end nonetheless come up brief within the MG, with extra exhausting plastics and fundamental trim than you’ll discover within the Leaf.
- • Gear: Heated leather-based seats are a part of an in depth equipment listing that the Leaf can’t match.
- • Tech: There’s a very good touchscreen, however you don’t get a hi-tech digital dashboard.
For: Trip and refinement higher than the MG’s, extra EV-orientated options, truthful degree of equipment even in base trim.
Towards: Vary isn’t pretty much as good, efficiency and practicality restricted in contrast with MG’s, pricier.
The second-generation Leaf is a closely up to date model of the unique with regards to the structure on which it’s based mostly. The large adjustments come courtesy of a much bigger 40kWh battery (of which round 36kWh is usable) supplying a extra highly effective 148bhp electrical motor.
Not like the MG although, the Leaf’s battery doesn’t function extra superior liquid cooling to control the cells’ temperature in use and when charging. Keep in mind that over a protracted time frame this might probably have an effect on the battery’s efficiency.
Because it stands, the Leaf’s efficiency is sound, taking 7.eight seconds to speed up from 0-60mph – a lot sooner than an equal combustion-engined automotive would take. Just like the MG, it’s really easy to do as effectively. With a single-speed transmission there are not any adjustments, so acceleration is easy.
Additionally just like the MG, the Leaf isn’t the best to drive. The connection between driver and steering is imprecise, compounded by the very fact the steering wheel doesn’t provide a large sufficient vary of adjustment; there’s solely the choice to vary rake, not attain.
Neither are the physique management or journey something to write down house about. The Leaf has much less variance between its finest and worst, smothering harsh bumps far more adeptly than the often crashy MG, however it doesn’t really feel fairly as gentle and forgiving because the ZS at its finest. Nevertheless, the Leaf is far more constant and composed, partly as a result of its journey top is decrease, so it doesn’t roll round as a lot.
The motor is smoother and its response is silkier, so it’s simpler to get the measure of, even when the Leaf’s efficiency lagged behind the ZS’s in our exams. Together with the 0-60mph evaluation, the Nissan trailed the MG by 0.1 and 0.2 seconds between 30-50mph and 50-70mph, at 2.eight and 4.6 seconds.
That is barely noticeable on the highway although. Nevertheless, the ZS’s liquid cooling means the MG’s efficiency and recharging charge must be extra constant than the Nissan’s, whereas the battery itself ought to have an extended life.
Just like the MG, high quality is common at finest, with the Leaf’s cabin clothed in exhausting plastics, whereas there’s loads of gear included even in base Acenta spec. You get a way more versatile seven-inch display screen subsequent to the speedo, which exhibits extra EV-specific data than the MG’s small display screen. The Nissan’s infotainment exhibits charging stations, too, whereas the MG exhibits petrol stations – it’s apparent it’s been carried over from the usual ZS.
The Leaf additionally comes with nice security tech, a rear-view digital camera, 16-inch alloys, adaptive cruise, local weather management and auto headlights.
- • Inside: Go for a Leaf Acenta, and also you don’t get as a lot equipment because the equally priced MG. The automotive in our footage is in well-specced Tekna trim.
- • Switches: Stubby drive selector sits subsequent to e-Pedal button for one-pedal driving.
- • High quality: Leaf feels just like the better-built product, however isn’t as far forward as you may count on.
First place: MG ZS EV
It’s removed from an ideal EV, however the MG affords extra vary, higher charging, stronger efficiency and equal effectivity to the Leaf, whereas it will get as a lot equipment for much less money. On this foundation the MG simply edges the Nissan – it’s a very good first EV effort from the Chinese language-owned British model.
Second place: Nissan Leaf
Nissan’s EV expertise exhibits right here, as a result of the Leaf is an efficient EV. Nevertheless, vary and recharging are nonetheless crucial and the Leaf simply isn’t as versatile because the ZS on this respect. The newer MG’s added skill demonstrates how rapidly electrical automotive improvement is shifting.